What Are Good Email Subject Lines for Real Estate Agents? (Tested Examples)

Your email content doesn't matter if nobody opens it.

Real estate agents send a lot of email — listing announcements, market updates, buyer follow-ups, just-sold announcements, event invites. The average open rate for real estate email is around 27%. That means nearly 3 out of 4 people on your list never read what you wrote.

The subject line is almost entirely responsible for that number.

Here's what actually works.

The 5 Subject Line Principles That Drive Opens

1. Specificity beats vagueness every time

"New listing in Austin" is worse than "New listing 4 blocks from Barton Springs — opens this weekend."

Specificity signals that this email is relevant. Vague subject lines read as "broadcast" — something sent to a list, not written for the reader.

2. Curiosity gaps work (when they're honest)

"I saw this and thought of you" — what did you see? People open to find out.

But never use curiosity bait that doesn't pay off in the email. "You won't believe this" followed by a mediocre market update is how you train people to stop opening.

3. Local beats generic

"Austin market update" is fine. "Why South Austin homes are selling in 9 days right now" is better. Your sphere is local — they care about their neighborhood, not the abstract "market."

4. Lowercase tends to outperform title case

Counterintuitive, but true. "i found the house you described" reads as a personal message. "I Found The House You Described" reads like a marketing email. The goal is personal, not polished.

5. Numbers and time references create urgency

"Open house this Sunday — 14 groups last time" feels real and immediate. "Open house at [address]" does not.

Subject Lines by Email Type

New Listing Announcements

• "Just listed: the [neighborhood] house you've been waiting for"
• "Before I post this publicly — [address] is live"
• "This one checks every box you've described"
• "New listing: 4/3 in [neighborhood], $485K, showing this weekend"
• "I found a good one. Open house Sunday."

Market Update Emails

• "[Neighborhood] homes: why they're selling in 8 days flat"
• "Quick market update — [month] by the numbers"
• "Is now a good time to buy in [city]? (honest answer)"
• "Inventory just hit a 3-year low in [area]. Here's what that means for you."
• "What I'm seeing in the market this week"

Open House Invitations

• "This Sunday — open house, light bites, no pressure"
• "You're invited to the open house at [address]"
• "Private preview before Sunday's open house — interested?"
• "I saved you a spot at [address] this weekend"
• "Come see why [neighborhood] buyers keep choosing this street"

Follow-Up After Meeting or Showing

• "Great meeting you Saturday"
• "The listing you asked about — update"
• "After our showing at [address]"
• "Quick thought after our conversation"

Just Sold Announcements

• "[Address] is under contract — faster than we expected"
• "Sold in 6 days, $15K over ask — here's how"
• "Another one sold in [neighborhood] — current owners, you might want to know this"
• "What this sale means for [neighborhood] values this quarter"

Buyer Nurture Sequences

• "The question every first-time buyer asks me"
• "3 things I wish someone had told me before buying in [city]"
• "You asked about [neighborhood] — here's my honest take"
• "Checking in — are you still looking, or has life gotten busy?"
• "The market changed since we last talked"

What About Emojis in Subject Lines?

Use them sparingly and only when they're genuinely relevant. A single emoji at the beginning or end of a subject line can increase opens — but more than one looks like spam.

Works: "New listing in Westlake 🏡 — open house Sunday" Doesn't: "✨ JUST LISTED! 🏡🔑 New 4BR Home In [City]! 🌟"

A/B Testing Your Subject Lines

If your email platform allows A/B testing (most do — Mailchimp, ConvertKit, etc.), run simple tests:

• Version A: "New listing in [neighborhood]"
• Version B: "This is the one you've been describing"

After 3–4 sends with the same pair, you'll have real data about what your specific list responds to. Most agents have never done this. It compounds over time.

The Subject Line Isn't Everything

Great subject lines get emails opened. What's inside keeps people on your list. If you consistently write emails that are worth reading — specific, local, genuinely useful — your open rates climb over time because people want to see what you wrote.

Think of the subject line as the door and the email as the room. The door gets them in. The room determines if they come back.

---

PropWrite generates complete email sequences for every listing — Just Listed, Open House Reminder, and Final Call — each with subject lines and body copy. Try it free.